8.
PASSAGE (Next 5 Questions)
Read the following passage and answer the questions based on it:
The fundamental and existential threat posed by the unparalleled proliferation of digital surveillance capabilities to democracy's foundational tenets is a clear contradiction between the demands of modern security and the ideals of individual liberty. It is now concretely known whether these technologies are compromising civil freedoms, rather than just an abstract theory. Facial recognition, bulk collection of data, and algorithmic tracking of online activity give governments and corporations the ability to exercise constant, detailed surveillance over the lives of citizens. All-encompassing surveillance has the potential to have a "chilling effect" - where citizens, aware of being spied upon, might censor themselves, restrict their activism, and refrain from articulating dissenting views, thus suppressing the very dissent and freedom of expression that are core to a healthy democracy. The possibility of using these tools for political repression, social control, and targeting marginalised communities poses a sinister downward slide toward a surveillance state where the assumption of innocence gives way to an assumption of suspicion.
The underlying conflict, then, is how to balance personal privacy against national security. Although there is a genuine need for governments to employ sophisticated technologies to respond to terrorism, organised crime, and other grave dangers, this must not be at the cost of the basic right to privacy. A good balance is a strong and open legal regime that subjects surveillance activities to rigorous judicial supervision and public accountability. Since technologies like end-to-end encryption are essential for protecting private communication, they should be supported and encouraged rather than compromised. In order to establish clear red linesโwhat data can be gathered, under what conditions, and for how longโsocieties must also participate in a continuous and collaborative public discussion. Whether freedom endures in the age of the internet depends upon our capacity to construct a system in which security is not a zero-sum affair with liberty but a system of confidence in which technology serves to safeguard citizens, not continually watch them.
What is the central contradiction discussed in the passage regarding digital surveillance?